How do you make your cinnamon toast?

I’ve been trying to be inspired to cool by actually reading the cookbooks I currently possess. I have to admit this isn’t something I’ve ever actually done before.

So while perusing Nigella Lawson’s How To Eat I ran across a sentence discussing the American comfort food of cinnamon toast. And she described how to make it as whipping together butter, sugar, and cinnamon.

I did a double take. Never in my life have I made cinnamon toast by blending anything. What on earth was she on about? Is it because she’s British and clearly has no clue?

Then it occured to me. Maybe *I* am the wierd one here. Maybe my mom is the one who doesn’t know how to make cinnamon toast. So I thought I’d take a look-see.

  • Cooks.com instructs you to mix sugar and cinnamon in a separate container, shake over already buttered toast, then broil until sugar bubbles. I never bothered with the separate container, it’s not exactly hard to shake it out of both the sugar and cinnamon containers. The broiling part sounds interesting, though.
  • Apparently there’s a cooking monkey who also bubbles his toast. Hmm.
  • With the exception of my already mentioned aversion to mixing the cinnamon and sugar, allrecipes.com does it like I do.
  • And so on and so forth. They pretty much all follow the above.

Hurrah! I’m not a freak. But I am intrigued by the broiling. I suddenly wish I had a toaster oven.

So how do YOU make your cinnamon toast?

3 Responses to “How do you make your cinnamon toast?”

  1. Wendy Says:

    Premix the sugar and cinnamon. I don’t measure anything, just look for a nice light brown color. Then I toast the bread in the toaster. When it is done, butter the toast. When the butter is melted onto the toast I sprinkle the cinnamon/sugar mix over it. No bubbling or broiling, though that sounds interesting.

  2. dottcomments Says:

    1. Butter the bread (generously). Hearty bread is good — something whole wheat or thickly-sliced sourdough is divine.

    2. Sprinkle on the sugar.

    3. Sprinkle on the cinnamon.

    4. Toast under the oven broiler (or toaster oven if you have one).

  3. Scott Says:

    What the hell is cinnamon toast? And “broil”?